As with "Meet the Parents," much of the appeal of the film rests with the leading players. Bryan Cranston, busting out the comedy chops honed on TV's "Malcolm in the Middle," plays Ned Fleming, CEO of a Michigan printing company on the decline in our paperless-trending world. While the screws keep tightening on his business and threatening layoffs of beloved workers, Ned gets some other disconcerting news: his 22-year-old daughter Stephanie (Zoey Deutch) — a student at Stanford University — has been secretly dating 32-year-old tech magnate Laird Mayhew, played by Palo Alto's own James Franco.
And so the Christmas-get-together plot pits Ned against Laird, a sweet-natured guy who's nevertheless blithely douche-y — from his conspicuous consumption (a 2018-model computerized Japanese toilet/bidet) to his tattoos and hipster mustache. Most of the comedy relies on generation-gap gags or toilet humor as Ned flails on Laird's nouveau-riche turf, complete with oddball lawn-to-table menu and an artwork consisting of a moose suspended in its own urine ("It's meant to symbolize the way our culture has imprisoned our minds").
"Why Him?" is nothing if not formulaic, but it has its passing charms, like Megan Mullally's fully committed, fully amusing performance as Ned's wife Barb (plus Keegan-Michael Key as Laird's try-hard valet) and its essentially generous nature, trusting in Stephanie's promise that Laird's "heart is always in the right place." Occasionally, there's an interesting bit of satire, like the young people being cheerily comfortable with total social transparency (a.k.a. a total lack of privacy).
Ultimately, the hackneyed plot (partly credited to Franco's buddy Jonah Hill) is too primal not to work, even if it is little more than the frame on which to hang stupid jokes, several of which you'll see coming a mile away (a silly cameo appearance, the fate of the urine-filled moose tank). In the end, to the extent that the movie works, it works because of Cranston and Franco, who work hard and smart to make their characters always at least as believable as they are funny.
Rated R for strong language and sexual material throughout. One hour, 51 minutes.
This story contains 469 words.
Stories older than 90 days are available only to subscribing members. Please help sustain quality local journalism by becoming a subscribing member today.
If you are already a subscriber, please log in so you can continue to enjoy unlimited access to stories and archives. Subscriptions start at $5 per month and may be cancelled at any time.