What can you do with your EV battery? | A New Shade of Green | Sherry Listgarten | Mountain View Online |

Local Blogs

A New Shade of Green

By Sherry Listgarten

E-mail Sherry Listgarten

About this blog: Climate change, despite its outsized impact on the planet, is still an abstract concept to many of us. That needs to change. My hope is that readers of this blog will develop a better understanding of how our climate is evolving a...  (More)

View all posts from Sherry Listgarten

What can you do with your EV battery?

Uploaded: Jan 23, 2022
I have heard from many of you who have EVs and would like to know when you will be able to use your car to power your house during a blackout, charge your laptop at a campground, or even contribute some power to the grid when there is a flex alert. This blog post is a short overview of where we are on those “vehicle-to-X” tasks. The topic is complicated -- a recent working group identified over 1000 use-cases for vehicle-grid integration which it “narrowed down” to 320. Plus the technology is quickly evolving. So this post will mostly touch on the surface and I may have some follow-ons as I learn more.

For those of you who like acronyms (anyone??), this subject is a gold mine. For the purpose of this blog post, I’ll stick with four: V1G, V2G, V2L, and V2H. (1) These stand for different ways that your EV battery can be deployed for uses beyond driving. I’m going to try to explain what these are and the current status, though I would love to hear from those of you who know more in the comments!

V1G: Charging your EV, ideally when there’s plenty of power

The simplest way to use your EV to help the grid is by adjusting when you charge it, for example to avoid peak periods (4-9pm) and to charge less on “flex alert” days. The number “1” in the V1G acronym refers to the uni-directional flow of charge from the grid to the EV. (The rest stands for “Vehicle to Grid”.) Anyone can do this (basically, charge at a different time), but power providers and third parties have been experimenting with how to better reward and aggregate this kind of “flexible demand” and make it more responsive to grid needs.

Today many of you can program your EVs to avoid charging during certain periods (e.g., evenings). But you won’t always know when the grid is stressed. Another option is to get a grid-aware charger (e.g., JuiceBox) that will charge your car at times that are best for the grid while respecting your charging needs. With JuiceBox, you can specify that you need your EV charged at a certain time, and you can specify if you have time-of-use rates that you would like it to respect. The charger company, Enel X, earns some money by providing this aggregated flexible demand to the grid, and in some locations EV owners can earn money as well.

Silicon Valley Clean Energy is promoting GridShift, which works with some vehicles and chargers. Peninsula Clean Energy is conducting managed pilots. After the recent summer power crunches, California is actively looking for ways to reduce demand during flex alerts and other peaks, and the state is funding and seeking to quickly develop and expand these managed charging programs.

Some of the issues they are trying to figure out include:
- What is the right way to incentivize EV owners to participate? How do you determine the baseline behavior to compare against, and is a special charger or meter needed?
- How “big” do these aggregated services need to be in order to register with the grid?
- How often and when will they be called upon to respond?
- If customers are already on time-of-use rates that discourage 4-9pm charging, are there other times/occasions when flexible demand would be helpful?

If you are interested in flexible charging, contact your local power provider to see what programs are available. This is an easy and inexpensive way to reduce our power peaks, increase reliability, and save money. In my view all power providers should be encouraging it. I hope the majority of chargers are participating in a few years’ time.

V2L: Charging a small load (L) from your EV

While “V1” refers to applications that charge the EV, “V2” refers to applications in which the EV is used to charge something else. That is, the EV is exporting power rather than importing it. In the case of “V2L”, the EV is used to directly power some load (“L”). This is a fancy way of saying that your EV has plugs.

A number of EVs are coming out with pretty powerful outlets. The Ford F-150 Lightning has up to 11 outlets with a total of 9.6 kW of power. The 240-volt outlet in the truck bed can even charge another EV! The Hyundai Ioniq 5 has an outlet on the outside of the car that can provide up to 1.9 kW. Kia, Toyota, and others have announced models with this feature as well. This seems pretty useful, with the primary downside being that if it’s overused it could drain or even degrade the battery.

Most EVs today do not support this capability. But if you know what you are doing, or if you trust videos on the internet made by preppers and frostbitten Texans, you can install an inverter like this, or even a kit, to convert the high-voltage direct current from your EV battery to lower-voltage alternating current that your appliances can use. If you are successful, you can plug in a coffee maker when you are car camping, or plug in a refrigerator during a power outage. I hope that more EVs start incorporating this feature so there’s less need to jerry-rig it.

V2H: Charging your home (H) from your EV

It is much simpler to charge a few appliances with your EV (e.g., via outlets or an add-on inverter) than it is to power a building with it. Not only is more power needed, but the inverter needs to be integrated with your electric panel, and your house needs a switch that will automatically disconnect your house from the grid when the power goes out. (You don’t want the power from your house feeding back onto the grid and potentially harming linemen.) This means permits and inspections and expense. If you think about it, this kind of setup is very similar to installing a home battery (albeit one on wheels).

The Ford F-150 Lightning supports this capability, and it is a big selling point for many buyers. But the installation is non-trivial. Ford provides its own "charging station" that needs to be professionally installed (they are partnering with SunRun for that), and it requires a 320-amp service.

Almost no cars are equipped with bidirectional chargers capable of powering a home. However, a few companies are developing external chargers that can do the job. These “DC chargers” convert the grid’s AC current to DC so they can deliver DC charge directly to the EV for faster charging. They can also convert large amounts of DC charge from the vehicle into the AC needed by the home. It is arguably easier to do this conversion outside of the car rather than inside the car since on-vehicle components have many constraints. (2) The Wallbox Quasar is one such product, and the dcbel Home Energy Station is another. Unfortunately they only work with cars with CHAdeMO connectors right now (e.g., Nissan Leaf and Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV). The CCS standard adopted by most other EVs in the US does now support bi-directional charging and some pilot projects are beginning to explore this. (3)

PG&E in particular is interested in seeing how much V2H can mitigate the impacts of its high-fire-danger power-shutoff (PSPS) events. The state is very supportive, in part because the generators that many households rely on are very polluting. A $7.5M PG&E pilot for residences will try to evolve the V2H technology while also learning how to deploy it most effectively.

If you have an EV and your home is in a PSPS area, ask your utility if there is a V2H pilot that you can participate in. Only a few types of vehicles are likely to be supported. If you are not eligible, my guess is it will be a few years before the market (e.g., vehicles and chargers and installers) has evolved to support the ability for a typical EV to power a home during outages.

V2G: Powering the grid (G) with your EV

Finally, it should be possible to send power from your EV battery onto the grid in times of need, in return for cold hard cash. This requires not only the infrastructure described above, but also some ability for the state’s electricity market to recognize this new type of generation, incorporate it, and compensate it.

If your EV is configured to export electricity, it could perform like a solar roof in some ways, providing power to your home or the grid, and it would need to be metered and wired in a similar way. The CPUC is in fact looking into extending the solar Net Metering rate structure to work with EV charging.

One question that people are trying to answer is how more frequent charging and discharging would impact the health of an EV battery. There is no clear answer yet since it depends on several factors. (4) I expect it is fine to respond to flex alerts and outages by exporting power from your EV battery, but it might be more problematic to send power to the grid every evening at 7pm.

Only 25% of the use cases that the working group looked at were residential. Other interesting cases involve fleets of school buses and transit buses, big drayage trucks that do short set routes between ports and warehouses, local delivery trucks, and airport shuttles. If done properly, V2G can reduce the costs of maintaining these electric fleets while also saving the grid money. In that sense, V2G can accelerate electrification by making it more affordable.

But getting it right, or even just making it work, involves coordination between the grid, the power providers, and vehicle manufacturers. With so many interested parties (1000+ use cases!) and the state’s very inclusive process, not to mention the technical and market complexity, the V2G discussions have been slow going. I think we will largely be in the “pilot” phase for a few more years.

I look forward to your comments and questions on this topic, and maybe I’ll do a more focused follow-on once I learn more.

Notes and References
1. There is also V2B (“Vehicle to Building”), V2X (“Vehicle to Anything”) and V2V (“Vehicle to Vehicle”, aka charging one EV from another EV).

2. I like this explanation of how onboard and offboard chargers compare.

3. PG&E's description of a pilot program they are planning says: “For vehicles that use the Combined Charging Standard (CCS) for DC charging, there are two existing pathways to enable bidirectional charging. One is through the DIN 70121 specification, and one is through the ISO 15118-20 specification. The DIN 70121 specification has been finalized and is therefore, currently more mature in functionality than the ISO 15118- 20 specification, which is targeted to be formalized sometime at the beginning of 2022.”

4. You can find a few references here and here and here and here (this last only if you have IEEE access, which I don’t!).

Current Climate Data (December 2021)
Global impacts, US impacts, CO2 metric, Climate dashboard

Comment Guidelines
I hope that your contributions will be an important part of this blog. To keep the discussion productive, please adhere to these guidelines or your comment may be moderated:
- Avoid disrespectful, disparaging, snide, angry, or ad hominem comments.
- Stay fact-based and refer to reputable sources.
- Stay on topic.
- In general, maintain this as a welcoming space for all readers.

Comments that are written in batches by people/bots from far outside of this community are being removed.
Democracy.
What is it worth to you?

Comments

 +   2 people like this
Posted by Judy LaRussa, a resident of Cuesta Park,
on Jan 23, 2022 at 10:36 am

Judy LaRussa is a registered user.

Fascinating article as I was unaware that an EV battery had so much auxiliary potential.

We have a Honda generator installed near the crawl space opening of our home but have never used it.

Can a conventional EV actually power a house and for how long?

And do hybrids offer the same possibilities but to a lesser extent?


 +   2 people like this
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Mountain View Online blogger,
on Jan 23, 2022 at 2:46 pm

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

@Judy, thanks for the question. A typical EV (e.g., with 200 mile range) will have a battery that can store around 60 kWh of energy. A typical home in California uses 20-30 kWh/day, so that is around 2-3 days' worth. You wouldn't want to drain the EV battery, but the point is it's more than enough for the kind of outages we see here.

Hybrids wouldn't work because they have much smaller batteries. Even most plug-in hybrids wouldn't do well. A Volt could work in a pinch. (It has an 18 kWh battery.)

I looked up a few statistics. There are more than 50,000 EVs in Santa Clara County with a range of 200 miles or more. (Source) So the aggregate energy they store is north of 3 GWh. The two million or so people in Santa Clara County used about 12 GWh/day in 2020. (Source). So that gives you an indication of just how much energy is in these EVs. The 50,000 longer-range EVs in the county could (theoretically) meet the daily electricity needs of about a quarter of all the residents of the county, or 500,000 people. The 3 GWh is far larger than any existing battery storage plant, and I think bigger than all of the grid battery storage that exists today in California. And it will just keep growing.

Because a significant amount of energy is stored in these vehicle batteries, and because EV sales are growing quickly, the state is very interested in understanding how to harness that energy when needed to stabilize the grid. It can save the grid money and also make EVs cheaper by rewarding that participation.


 +   4 people like this
Posted by David+Coale, a resident of Barron Park,
on Jan 23, 2022 at 4:40 pm

David+Coale is a registered user.

Another interesting post. Here are a few comments.

V1G: Driving on Sunshine. You can charge mainly from the sun even if you don't have solar panels on your roof. If you can charge your EV between about 9 am and 3 pm you are charging your car on sunshine as there is a lot of solar on the grid during the day. While charging at night (after 9) is also good to avoid peak demand hours, at night you are charging largely on fossil fuel based electricity. See the California ISO web site to see when the most renewables are on the grid: Web Link

Another tip: If you want to set some sort of hours for charging your EV, make sure you set this on the home charger if possible and not on the car. Why? When you travel some place else and need to charge right away, your car will be ready instead of waiting for off peak hours, which could leave you stranded if the car is not charging.

For V2L, most of these DIY and kit solutions actually connect to the EV's 12 volt system, so that you are limited to about 1,000 watts of power. This is a good solution to keep your refrigerator running and to run a few lights and charge cell phones, but is probably short of running your house, but is really good for emergency situations. You just need to understand the limitations and be good at DIY projects.

Hopefully we will see more EVs like the Ford F150 that will be able to take the place of a home back up generator and be able to run your house for days.

David


 +   3 people like this
Posted by Ronen, a resident of Menlo Park,
on Jan 24, 2022 at 12:06 am

Ronen is a registered user.

Excellent article. Thank you.
I got my EV last month and have been trying to figure out how to use it to power the house during outages.

Skeptics are always talking about how EVs will increase demand for electricity and destabilize our grid. I think the opposite is true. With all that stored energy, we'll be able to smooth peaks and troughs in consumption, and won't have to curtail renewable consumption when it's abundant. The disaster recovery options that EVs create alone are promising.

I try to charge the car during morning hours, to drive mostly on sunshine as David suggested. Off-peak nightly charging is supposedly cheaper, but charging mostly from fossil gas defeats the purpose. No more GHG for my car, if I can help it.

Although my wife and my son each still have an ICE vehicle, we've decided that all trips are done in the EV. If there's a conflict, whoever has the longest trip takes the EV.

Next up, home batteries, followed by a heat pump. Cut those carbon emissions!


 +   2 people like this
Posted by Lauritzen, a resident of Gemello,
on Jan 24, 2022 at 11:14 am

Lauritzen is a registered user.

The EV fleet must become an integral part of the utility grid. Consider this; 30% of all California cars to be electric with an average 300 mile range/100KWh battery. If that fleet is two-way (V2L) grid connected, it alone can power California for nearly 2 hours while depleting the EV batteries only 15%.

It does not make sense to start installing a myriad of residential battery packs because it will be expensive. In addition, consider the life cycle/handling of the batteries. There will be well established recycling of EV battery packs. Not necessarily so with anything of less volume. Finally, residential battery packs are on the order of 10KWh which is just 10% the size an EV battery pack.

Solutions such as the F150 is cute but impractical for anyone but a contractor with need for on-the-job off-grid power.


 +   1 person likes this
Posted by Bill Michel, a resident of another community,
on Jan 24, 2022 at 7:11 pm

Bill Michel is a registered user.

The Quasar is not being sold in the US. Quasar 2 will be, and it will be CCS... *and*, the Company is in Mountain View... how 'bout that?!

Dcbel looks pretty killer, though their marketing dept. needs some help. I
think the actual unit is called R16, or something else memorable... ! ;-)


 +   1 person likes this
Posted by Michael, a resident of Menlo Park: The Willows,
on Jan 28, 2022 at 10:21 am

Michael is a registered user.

Fairly certain Teslas are capable bidirectional charging but Musk does not believe its a good idea. They believe stationary batteries are the answer for home backup.


 +   1 person likes this
Posted by EPL, a resident of Menlo Park: The Willows,
on Jan 29, 2022 at 4:34 pm

EPL is a registered user.

Great topic, again.

It might be useful to expand a bit on how to control the load on the grid from charging the EV. One way is to do it at the charger but that needs a connected charger and some of us have a dumb charger - in my case I chose one to minimize the number of things that can go wrong. Another approach is to connect directly to the car and direct its charging time and load. Turns out that many cars provide this, in part because customers want to be able to control features of they car remotely. That is the project pilot that PCE is doing.

Re: CCS standard at home; I know that there are products in Germany that provide DC charging at 22kW. A family member has one that connects to the Solar panels, the battery and has an integrated DC charger. I am not sure the status of V2H/V2G in Germany, but I believe it is pretty close; I know that VW has indicated their new models will all support V2<something> in 2022 [and, they even promised they will upgrade the 2021 to it... we will see]


Follow this blogger.
Sign up to be notified of new posts by this blogger.

Email:

SUBMIT

Post a comment

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed.

Get the day's top headlines from Mountain View Online sent to your inbox in the Express newsletter.

Palo Alto location of popular Austrian restaurant Naschmarkt opens May 17
By The Peninsula Foodist | 1 comment | 3,205 views

We need stable, climate-forward land use policies
By Sherry Listgarten | 4 comments | 3,106 views

Use Your Words!
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 1,595 views

Dehydrating for Backpacking and Camping
By Laura Stec | 2 comments | 1,465 views